Factors in farmland valuations


By Tim Cobb
Owner, Farmland Company

wheat field

“What is the value of my farm property?” This is perhaps the most common and subjective question fielded each day in the market-driven world of agricultural real estate. The answer, of course, is a resounding, “It depends.”

Price discovery, as defined by time-tested text and the modern everyday application, is nothing short of the point where a willing seller and a willing buyer arrive at a meeting of the minds and agree to transact/trade something of value for something of value. 

The value of farmland is determined through a sequence of steps. First, the purpose and scope of the valuation define the appropriate approach. Next, local and external influences on value are carefully analyzed to produce a valuation range. That range is then refined with adjustments that account for differences among properties. Finally, like-kind current market sales and production capacity are used to arrive at the final value.

Sounds easy enough. However, the reality is that no two pieces of property — farmland especially — are identical, nor are the circumstances of the ownership consistent with given impacts that play into what it takes to arrive at the convergence of value. 

Purpose and scope

Every farmland valuation begins with its purpose: why the value is needed determines the approach that follows. If considered in the form of a question, one might say, “I am looking to know the current value of my farm for the purpose of_______.” The most common answers include:

  • Potential sale
  • Lending
  • Estate planning
  • Taxation 
  • Investment analysis 
  • External impact (conservation or development)
  • Ownership transition

Each of the above becomes a starting point to help anchor the analysis and define each point of reference that will be used to arrive at a final valuation reconciliation. 

The scope of value will further dive deeper to consider the impacts to value that come from the property rights themselves, such as how the land is owned (fee simple or undivided share interests); leasehold interests including the duration of a given lease; associated water and mineral rights; title considerations; access; and/or other agreed-upon existing encumbrances. 

Local and external impacts

The factors that affect the valuation of farmland include:

  • Physical characteristics of the property, such as soil class and productivity, drainage, slope/topography, parcel shape and field size, access, and ability to operate modern equipment in an efficient manner. Also considered is the land use mix and crop rotation including irrigated vs. dryland production, pasture, orchard, timber, or other specialty production. Finally, existing improvements are evaluated, such as wells and irrigation equipment, fencing, grain storage, shops, houses, road type, and proximity to utilities. 
  • Location, rainfall, and market access, including proximity to grain elevators, processors, packing houses, feedlots, and ports via highways or rail systems. Distance to farm-related services, equipment and repair dealers, affordable housing for a robust labor pool, and other ag-related businesses. Influence of urban growth, commercial development, and rural residential/recreational demands. Competing land use has become more pointed and cause the values of farmland to outpace the ability of a producer to create a mitigated return on investment.
  • External market risk factors to consider include global commodity price volatility at unseasonal times and regional yield variation in response to climate-related incidents, such as drought, flooding, heat, fire, and smoke. Unseen factors on the horizon for any piece of farmland include tenant transition, lease renewal pressure, environmental compliance, municipal regulation, resource limitations from availability of seed, fertilizer, and irrigation curtailment events that cause disruption.  

Income production, market-comparable sales

Following these considerations, the central factors in valuing farmland are the integrity of participation in an open market and the reliability of each property’s income production.

Historical yields, crop rotations, production history, and variability in output play a critical role in understanding what the land can bear. The land will always tell the truth as to its inherent value when given parameters that align with the market.

All sources of income are included as value factors, including cash rent or crop share arrangements, specific lease terms, and the quality of the tenant relationship. Lastly, some analysis of access to farm “safety nets,” such as government programs, crop insurance participation, conservation payments, and other reoccurring income sources, all help the market arrive at a value.

Perhaps you wonder why I would end with what is so often the beginning of reliable farm valuation. After all, “What my neighbor sold for (or said they sold for) should be what my ground is worth today.” However, while recent like-kind comparable sales, adjusted for land class, improvements, and farmer and investor demand, play an important role, there will always be property-specific adjustments that take into account other market and economic conditions. These include interest rates, inflation, financing terms, buyer and seller motivation, alternative investments, access to capital, and credit strength of the industry. 

In Eastern Washington, as in real estate everywhere, valuation owes something to the old saying, “location, location, location.” For farmland, that often becomes “water, water, water” or “soil, soil, soil.” Yet no single factor ever tells the whole story. The most accurate value comes from weighing them all together.  

Tags

It’s been an honor serving
By Gil Crosby
President, Washington Association of Wheat Growers
Factors in farmland valuations
By Tim Cobb
Owner, Farmland Company
Farmers looking out for farmers
By Gil Crosby
President, Washington Association of Wheat Growers